If it was a hole and looked like that when viewed from below in the first panels, the tail on the speech balloon would be on the top side of it when viewed from above, not the bottom
No, I think what our Canadian friend is saying is that the hole in the last panel has an incongruent perspective. When the camera is top side looking down at the hole, the hole shape should be mirrored. If you consider the character topside looking down in the third panel, the little tail of the speech bubble hole is on their right, but in the fourth panel it is on their left.
That’s because of “artistic interpretation” to make the “gag” simpler to get, as the form of the black and white speech bubbles are the same in the panels.
So even if the “perspective”(well, it’s inside out sort of) is wrong, I’ll allow it.
No, I disagree with your interpretation. I think that when you ar in a dark place, a friendly voice can bring you out. I am not sure what your ‘geometry’ is saying. WTF?
The original commenter in this chain was making a point that the speech bubble is vertically flipped once he’s out of the hole. That’s all, he wasn’t saying anything about the deeper message of the comic.
The hole doesn’t make sense in the last panel and it’s wrecking my brain.
The speech curl should be on the opposite side in the last panel, otherwise it makes sense.
But it would have been visually confusing if it had been correct, making it look like the rescuer was the one speaking the dark hole.
If it was a hole and looked like that when viewed from below in the first panels, the tail on the speech balloon would be on the top side of it when viewed from above, not the bottom
When you are in a dark place, a single voice can bring light.
No, I think what our Canadian friend is saying is that the hole in the last panel has an incongruent perspective. When the camera is top side looking down at the hole, the hole shape should be mirrored. If you consider the character topside looking down in the third panel, the little tail of the speech bubble hole is on their right, but in the fourth panel it is on their left.
That’s because of “artistic interpretation” to make the “gag” simpler to get, as the form of the black and white speech bubbles are the same in the panels.
So even if the “perspective”(well, it’s inside out sort of) is wrong, I’ll allow it.
😋
I think it makes it harder to get. I was confused by the perspective without the reversed view of the hole.
I thank you for your interpretation. I disagree.
You disagree with… geometry?
No, I disagree with your interpretation. I think that when you ar in a dark place, a friendly voice can bring you out. I am not sure what your ‘geometry’ is saying. WTF?
The original commenter in this chain was making a point that the speech bubble is vertically flipped once he’s out of the hole. That’s all, he wasn’t saying anything about the deeper message of the comic.
I don’t understand why
From the perspective of the guy in the hole, the line should be pointing up after he is out.
Oh sure fair enough