Ukraine is set to field its first officially codified domestically built grenade launcher armed ground robot, after the Ministry of Defense approved the Droid NW 40 robotic combat system for service with the country’s Defense Forces, developer DevDroid said on December 23.
A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.
A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.
A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.
From the first time I read this as a kid, I recognized that in order for a robot to adhere to these rules, they would have to be programmed with these rules. A bad-faith robot builder could simply not include that programming.
A bad-faith robot builder like literally every one that accepts US government contracts.
Must. Make. More. Paperclips.
I believe this is only for fully autonomous robots. These are human controlled, more like an rc car with an upgrade.
But there are aerial drones currently in use that have AI targeting.
Actually autonomous? Or guided by computer vision? Technically CV is AI but not what concerns most people.
Ukraine has autonomous drones as autonomous as “there must be a tank around these parts, go destroy it!” and it executes.
Now they even recognize the type of tanks, their armor, so that they target its known weak point, and if it can’t, it targets the turret to make it at least unusable.
They probably have something similar as a submarine drone they used to sink the Russian submarine (it was most likely too far and underwater for remote control, and the drones had to pick the right target, or had a precise map and not lose positioning).
So they’re probably close to make these slaughterbots also autonomous to some degree.
I never imagined humanoid shapes to be the perfect Terminators except for infiltration anyway…
Right off the factory floor they are programmed to increase shareholder value. Some of them become accountants.
Which this article is not about.
Asimov wasn’t any more of a legislator than Dante was a theologian
I don’t think it will be programmed that way.
The writer of the laws himself made his career by writing an entire book series with stories about pointing out where the laws break down.
He did also do some stories about ‘fixing’ the laws but in every case that resulted in either limiting the robots capabilities in a restricting way or requiring them to have more power over people in ways that could be harmful to humanites self autonomy in the longrun.
In this case I think they’re broken down immediately because they won’t be used.
Spend months in a meeting room with everything from ethicists and philosopher to machine learning specialists and developers to figure out each nuance of the rules
or program it to kill everything until the batteries run down and send it out within the hour
The answer in a war is always the second option.
Screamers. Check it out.
There are loops. Killing a few Russian invaders will prevent many Ukrainian killings.
There’s at least one story I can remember about that.
I don’t think it’s a loophole. Surgeons hurt people in order to prevent a greater pain. ruZZia is just a cancer.
It’s seen as an unexpected loophole in the books. Similar to how a surgeon won’t kill one healthy person to save two with their organs.
At least on I,Robot
Edit: also, on I,Robot they harmed very specific people with very calculated results. Not like going to war, even on the defensive side.
Where’s this from?
They are Isaac Asimov’s rules for robots. Google it, it’s a whole thing.
The Foundation adaptation on AppleTV. Where, famously, spoilers
Tap for spoiler
Demerzel, this robot in the gif, kills lots of people by exploring the loophole that let robots commit genocide in supposed compliance with the 3 laws.
Holy shit. Random, I know but you just convinced me to check this out.
the show is solid
If you start on season 1, don’t let that dumpster fire dissuade you from the rest of the show. Once you get past that, the show is solid
the empire story line is basically what holds that season together imo
They also explore this on I, Robot