That’s the endgame, isn’t it? Not only is it going to be forced on us with promises that it will be our assistant we can delegate things to, but we will also we accountable for its calamities for “not having monitored it good enough”.
I work in radiology and I’ve been saying this for years. AI tools probably won’t replace us because of liability. We will have all of the liability while AI tools push us to work faster and faster for less money. I suspect this will happen with a lot of jobs.
I don’t know how it works with radiology, but my experience in software engineering is that reviewing the slop code takes more time than writing it, especially when it is crap and you have to send it back again and again and then review it.
At this point I either have to go through honestly which is extremely slow and frustrating to both sides, or accept the slop without review and then deal with tech debt later.
Well in radiology we are searching images for specific findings so the generative slop problem isn’t the issue for us, it will be being overwhelmed with false positives or false negatives with a time pressure to go faster. I’ve been trying to follow the impacts of these models on the coding professions and I do not envy you at all. It really does seem like a rock and a hard place right now.
It takes less efffort to eliminate the man whipping you than it takes to perform the work at the unreasonable rate your current whip demands. Delay work, Deny work, Defend your fellow workers. Turn the weapons of the oppression against it, UNITE, UNIONISE!
like some posts on the subs, they probably want to staff hospitals less and put all the work on the few mds they hire, to squeeze out more work for them, without hiring more radiologists,MD.
It’s like the tesla “self-driving” cars which were rushed through to production without thorough testing, then elon made all sorts of promises about how safe they were, but then they start every session with a disclaimer that says “driver must remain alert at all times; if the vehicle crashes, it’s your responsibility.”
The trick is end users will be held accountable for things their AI does, while corporations and governments will say “an AI did it” and wash their hands of it.
The problem with this is that the corpos will fight each other over IP/copyright/liscensing laws.
Yeah, if they can work out some kind a framework, then when blam, that is neo/technofuedalism formalized.
But the problem is that they are, in addition to ravenously insane, greedy as fuck.
Our legal system is slowly building precedent for how this kind of shit will shake out in court… but there are no broadly well understood and clear guidelines here, there’s no framework for this.
But!
They’re doing move fast and break things with trillions of dollars.
And when the spinning plates start flying apart, they will eat each other, it will be complete fucking chaos, because they moved way faster than apparently their ability to even consider or estimate what the rules for this will look like.
They did not think any of this shit through, at all.
That’s the endgame, isn’t it? Not only is it going to be forced on us with promises that it will be our assistant we can delegate things to, but we will also we accountable for its calamities for “not having monitored it good enough”.
I work in radiology and I’ve been saying this for years. AI tools probably won’t replace us because of liability. We will have all of the liability while AI tools push us to work faster and faster for less money. I suspect this will happen with a lot of jobs.
I don’t know how it works with radiology, but my experience in software engineering is that reviewing the slop code takes more time than writing it, especially when it is crap and you have to send it back again and again and then review it.
At this point I either have to go through honestly which is extremely slow and frustrating to both sides, or accept the slop without review and then deal with tech debt later.
Both options are bad.
Well in radiology we are searching images for specific findings so the generative slop problem isn’t the issue for us, it will be being overwhelmed with false positives or false negatives with a time pressure to go faster. I’ve been trying to follow the impacts of these models on the coding professions and I do not envy you at all. It really does seem like a rock and a hard place right now.
It takes less efffort to eliminate the man whipping you than it takes to perform the work at the unreasonable rate your current whip demands. Delay work, Deny work, Defend your fellow workers. Turn the weapons of the oppression against it, UNITE, UNIONISE!
like some posts on the subs, they probably want to staff hospitals less and put all the work on the few mds they hire, to squeeze out more work for them, without hiring more radiologists,MD.
And that’s one of the few fields where it makes sense too. A system that circles potential areas of interest on medical scans is a useful thing.
It’s like the tesla “self-driving” cars which were rushed through to production without thorough testing, then elon made all sorts of promises about how safe they were, but then they start every session with a disclaimer that says “driver must remain alert at all times; if the vehicle crashes, it’s your responsibility.”
What a fucking joke.
The trick is end users will be held accountable for things their AI does, while corporations and governments will say “an AI did it” and wash their hands of it.
The problem with this is that the corpos will fight each other over IP/copyright/liscensing laws.
Yeah, if they can work out some kind a framework, then when blam, that is neo/technofuedalism formalized.
But the problem is that they are, in addition to ravenously insane, greedy as fuck.
Our legal system is slowly building precedent for how this kind of shit will shake out in court… but there are no broadly well understood and clear guidelines here, there’s no framework for this.
But!
They’re doing move fast and break things with trillions of dollars.
And when the spinning plates start flying apart, they will eat each other, it will be complete fucking chaos, because they moved way faster than apparently their ability to even consider or estimate what the rules for this will look like.
They did not think any of this shit through, at all.