-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

mDMEafbs3xYJKwYBBAHaRw8BAQdAxFHIngmCNBKUXp4t5R4ToupZwLsfKC0ex0f+

s1i9Ks20IE9wcHJlc3NlZCBCcmVhZCA8bWRiZkBtb2NrdXAubWU+iHIEExYIABoE

CwkIBwIVCAIWAQIZAQWCafbs3wKeAQKbAwAKCRCvWf/f3nxNWI5ZAP96UMzv9+Fw

HN8caFzuEhsfYlG+gTTwCyQW+pxrEtbMngEA5hmEQCAtR1Hn0wtklx+oEQLyrbyB

1YrQ9/6BEMdSEQG4OARp9uzfEgorBgEEAZdVAQUBAQdAq08GhqDfQcv4SReA4yIR

q+tqu9+r5CzmGl6lU7sY0lQDAQgHiGEEGBYIAAkFgmn27N8CmwwACgkQr1n/3958

TVhHiQD+LZRUqwF5rQN4nD6zDjJz9fc9QtiBuX6CTijHbEf0rj8A/2kaxMHCqYTY

3wjNyL7l244OkfXrMUht0UFn/xx8mcEF

=L2Rb

-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

  • 5 Posts
  • 27 Comments
Joined 13 days ago
cake
Cake day: April 29th, 2026

help-circle














  • You’re right that the GNU toolchain is massive, but the distinction lies in "modularity versus integration". GNU tools are a collection of separate programs that happen to work together, you can swap bash for zsh or ls for busybox without breaking the whole system. systemd, however, is a tightly coupled suite where the init, logging, networking, and DNS are interdependent.

    The ‘idea of Linux’ isn’t just about running big software, it’s about the ability to compose a system from independent parts.

    When a single project dictates the entire stack and makes it nearly impossible to replace just one component without rewriting half the OS, that crosses the line from toolchain to platform lock-in, which is a fundamentally different threat to user freedom than a collection of large but separable GNU utilities.





  • It’s Open Source. Nobody needs to use it

    I didn’t mention anything about people needing to use it.

    You have distros that have communal decision making, and if they find a benefit to systemd, then they’ll use systemd. Don’t use that distro if you don’t like it. There’s your freedom of choice.

    I don’t have an issue with distros using systemd, my issue lies in how major distributions implemented systemd, which created an environment where app developers have to build for the most common init system in mind, you don’t think that’s an issue? having apps only compatible with one init system like how some apps are only compatible with windows, that’s not libre, its still pushing users towards a specific obvious choice