• 109 Posts
  • 236 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 30th, 2023

help-circle

  • I was deep in the weeds of the ACA fight and this is not at all how it went down. Democrats had a filibuster-proof majority for only a few months altogether, and many in the caucus at the time were moderate red-state Democrats that didn’t support a universal system. Hell, one of them, Joe Lieberman, had actively campaigned for John McCain and was on the shortlist to be his VP!

    The ACA that passed via reconciliation was the most progressive possible version of it that could have passed; lose one senator or a couple of representatives in the final vote and it would have failed to pass (and arguably destroyed Obama’s presidency in the process).






  • How to account for their success with music and visual art, though? Midjourney was making beautiful, intriguing images years ago, and AI music can be genuinely catchy and surprising. Again, the mainline models on default settings are pretty meh, but models tuned to the task are near-human quality. If there were enough of a commercial demand for high-level literary fiction to incentivize analyzing story structures, prosody, metaphor, etc., I don’t doubt they could rapidly improve on that front as well.


  • I suspect most of this is due to imperfect RLHF that focuses on brand-safety and rhetorical tricks that get annoyingly noticeable when they’re repeated at an industrial scale. The models are approaching superhuman ability at coding and math, but primarily because they’re more easily verifiable (plus it’s where the money is). But if there were a more rigorous way to quantify what makes good fiction work, there’s no reason in principle why a strong model wouldn’t be able to “optimize” it the same way it can images or video.

    I’ve fine-tuned a local model on my own writing before and it’s spooky how well it can capture a stylistic voice.