The U.S. judge overseeing Donald Trumpās prosecution for allegedly criminally conspiring to overturn Joe Bidenās election victory said that while every American has a First Amendment right to free speech, it is ānot absoluteā and that even the former presidentās campaign statements must yield to protecting the integrity of the judicial process.
In her first hearing over Trumpās federal case in D.C., U.S. District Judge Tanya S. Chutkan said that āthe fact that he is running a political campaignā will have no bearing on her decisions and āmust yield to the orderly administration of justice.ā
āIf that means he canāt say exactly what he wants to say about witnesses in this case, then thatās how itās going to be,ā Chutkan said Friday, repeatedly warning the former president and his defense about limits on what he can potentially reveal about government evidence in the case. āTo the extent your client wants to make statements on the internet, they have to always yield to witness security and witness safety.ā
āI caution you and your client to take special care in your public statements about this case,ā the judge said after the 90-minute hearing, āI will take whatever measures are necessary to safeguard the integrity of these proceedings.ā
Chutkanās warnings laid down an early marker in the case, even as she settled a fight between the sides over a protective order needed to speed the prosecutionās handover of materials and the courtās setting of a trial date, which special counsel Jack Smithās team has proposed for Jan. 2.
In the hearing, Chutkan rejected the governmentās request for a blanket protective order limiting sharing of all evidence released in the case. However, she mostly sided with prosecutors in granting them leeway to define āsensitiveā materials subject to greater protections, adding that Trumpās defense had agreed to similar conditions in his pending special counsel prosecution in Florida on charges of mishandling classified documents and obstruction.
This is the best summary I could come up with:
The U.S. judge overseeing Donald Trumpās prosecution for allegedly criminally conspiring to overturn Joe Bidenās election victory said that while every American has a First Amendment right to free speech, it is ānot absoluteā and that even the former presidentās campaign statements must yield to protecting the integrity of the judicial process.
Chutkanās warnings laid down an early marker in the case, even as she settled a fight between the sides over a protective order needed to speed the prosecutionās handover of materials and the courtās setting of a trial date, which special counsel Jack Smithās team has proposed for Jan. 2.
However, she mostly sided with prosecutors in granting them leeway to define āsensitiveā materials subject to greater protections, adding that Trumpās defense had agreed to similar conditions in his pending special counsel prosecution in Florida on charges of mishandling classified documents and obstruction.
Prosecutors have proposed adopting similar rules to a recent federal criminal case in Washington, prohibiting disclosure of government-provided materials to anyone outside his legal team, potential witnesses, their lawyers or others approved by the court.
They also sought to widen disclosure to include āvolunteer attorneysā or others not directly employed by his lawyers, and asked Chutkan for the freedom to cite sensitive information in public court filings or hearings without prior approval as long as it was redacted.
Chutkan has taken a firm stance toward Trumpās attorneys regarding deadlines at the outset of his case ā declining to a grant extensions to respond to the governmentās late-night Aug. 4 motion for a protective order or for setting Fridayās hearing ā and has earned a reputation as the toughest sentencer in the federal court in Washington of defendants charged in the riot.
Iām a bot and Iām open source!